Skip to content

HoltonArmsPrep by EduAvenues is an independent service, not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Holton-Arms School.

All guides

Holton-Arms teacher recommendations: what the forms ask

Holton-Arms asks for three teacher recommendations on common AISGW forms. See who writes each one, what the forms ask and how to prepare teachers.

Holton-Arms asks Upper School and Middle School applicants for three teacher recommendations, and it links the exact forms its teachers will fill out. They are common forms from the Association of Independent Schools of Greater Washington (AISGW), written for use across its member schools. This guide explains who writes each one, what each form asks, and how a parent can make the job easier for the teachers.

Who writes what

For grades 7 to 12, Holton-Arms says it requires three teacher recommendations: an English teacher, a math teacher, and a third teacher of the family's choosing. The school says the third teacher should be someone familiar with the applicant, such as an athletic coach, mentor, art teacher or music teacher. Forms can be submitted through the admissions portal.

Lower School applicants for grades 3 to 6 need two recommendations from the applicant's current teachers, on a Common Recommendation Form that the school makes available through its admissions portal. The Lower School page links that form to the AISGW student evaluation for grades 2 to 12, the same form older applicants' third teachers use. Holton-Arms welcomes additional letters from other teachers, coaches, mentors and friends. They are not required, and they can be sent to admissions@holton-arms.edu.

The parent's part

Each form starts with a section for the parent or guardian. You fill in the applicant's name and the grade applied to, then read and sign a waiver of the right to access the recommendation. Students entering ninth grade or higher sign too. You give each teacher a signed copy and ask them to send it to the school by its due date.

The forms say the recommendations stay confidential to the extent allowed by law when the waiver is signed, and that the form is one piece of the profile and does not become part of the student's permanent record. In plain terms, you won't see what teachers write, and the teachers know it. The forms ask teachers to be candid about the student's ability and motivation.

The English teacher form

The English form for grades 6 to 12 asks whether the teacher teaches the student, the size of the instructional group, and the subject and grade the student received. Then the teacher rates the student against others on a scale that runs from "One of the Best Ever" to "Poor," plus "No Opportunity to Observe." There are two groups.

  • Academic qualities cover study habits, attention span, working independently, organizing and communicating ideas, motivation, intellectual curiosity, critical and abstract thinking, and engagement.
  • Personal qualities cover creativity, self-confidence, leadership potential, reaction to criticism and setbacks, concern for others, conduct, integrity, acting independently, working cooperatively, maturity, sense of humor, interaction with adults and peers.

Then come written questions. They ask the teacher to compare the student's achievement with their ability, and to assess reading and writing, including interest in reading beyond assigned work. They also ask about the strengths and weaknesses of the student's written work, overall strengths and weaknesses, the reading and writing load in the course, whether absences have affected performance, and a comment on the student as a person. The form ends with a recommendation level, from "Enthusiastically" to "Not at All," for academic promise, character and overall.

The math teacher form

The math form uses the same ratings, with an explanation required for any rating of below average or poor. It adds a family section, where the teacher indicates how consistently the family communicates openly with the school, follows its policies, cooperates with teachers and follows through on recommendations.

The math-specific questions ask what course the student is enrolled in, whether the section is remedial, regular, advanced or mixed-ability, and what math placement the teacher suggests for next year. The teacher is also asked to describe the student in math, including how well they retain relationships and principles, generalize, apply principles in word problems, and rely on memory versus understanding.

The third teacher form

The common student evaluation form is the broadest. It asks how long the teacher has known the student, what three words come to mind, and whether there is anything unique about the student, such as a special talent, being bilingual or a particular family situation. It rates personal characteristics and academic performance against what is typical for the student's age, on a scale from advanced to needs improvement. It also asks about strengths and gifts, challenges, and what kind of classroom environment would suit the student. Like the math form, it has a family section.

The third teacher can speak to parts of your child the other two may not see. If your child leads a team, plays an instrument or works hard in a class that isn't core, this is the teacher who can describe it.

Choosing and asking well

  • Pick English and math teachers who teach your child in the school year you apply. Holton-Arms asks for current teachers.
  • For the third teacher, choose by how well they know your child, not by title or the grade given.
  • Ask early, hand over a signed form, and say the date the school needs it. Teachers write many of these.
  • Give each teacher a short note about what your child has been working on. It helps them offer specific examples.

Our guide to Holton-Arms testing and application requirements covers the rest of the file, and the admissions page has the overview.

When you're ready to prepare, the self-paced prep course follows this plan step by step, and the free application planner keeps the dates in one place.

Sources